“The first rule of any game is to know you’re in one.”
Sandy Lerner, co-founder of Cisco Systems
Art by: Microsoft Copilot, powered by DALL-E 3
Overview
At the beginning of the conflict now known as the Second Punic War, Hannibal Barca had a plan, and it was a good one. A proud son (and a gifted general) of Carthage, at the time an antagonist to the Roman Republic, Hannibal felt certain that he had identified the mortal weakness of his adversary. Roman superiority in manpower and resources was undeniable, but Hannibal believed that these advantages could be overcome by breaking the web of alliances that Roman might relied upon. Further, he believed that by seizing the initiative and bringing the fight to Italy, Hannibal could strike a mortal blow against his enemy. A few victories on Italian soil, he believed, and Rome’s allies would abandon their erstwhile patron, allowing Carthage to take its place as the dominant power of the Mediterranean.
In the early stages, things went according to plan. Hannibal shocked contemporaries by crossing the Alps with a massive army and in so doing seized the initiative. He crushed a Roman army at the Battle of Trebia and another at Lake Trasimene. Rome and her allies were stunned. Surely, the ultimate victory was within Hannibal’s grasp.
The Battle of Lake Trasimene was in 217 BCE. Fifteen years later, in 202 BCE, the might of Carthage was broken at the Battle of Zama, in North Africa. The Second Punic War was at an end, and Rome was victorious. What happened?
What happened was that Roman leadership had a different perspective on the deadly game in which both Rome and Carthage were engaged. Roman leadership, by choosing and acting in furtherance of a strategy framework that was orthogonal to Hannibal’s thesis, adhered to a key dictum of Sun Tzu: they knew themselves and they knew their enemy, and so they prevailed. Hannibal knew neither, and so, despite his many victories, he lost the war.
Strategy Drives Everything
In our contemporary business environment, it is critical for those in leadership to first have a clear understanding of the strategic game they are playing and second be engaged in a constant process of interrogating the appropriateness of that particular game. This is not an ivory tower exercise, rather it is a matter of critical importance to the long-term success and value creation potential of an organization, regardless of size or type. Success or failure for many organizations is often dependent on the ability of leadership to identify, refine, and execute the right strategy in the context of prevailing competitive dynamics. When leaders fall into the trap of thinking of their strategy as fixed, or when they misinterpret or ignore competitive dynamics, they run the risk of significant value destruction, with Research in Motion's (RIM) long slide from market dominance to irrelevance following Apple's launch of the iPhone serving as an illustrative example.
Leadership plays a vital role in crafting strategy. The best leaders recognize that their highest and best use is as force multipliers, and as such they strive to offer vision, direction, and inspiration to their organizations. These individuals must be adept at assessing internal and external factors and making informed decisions that position their organizations for long-term success.
Leaders must also be agile and adaptable, ready to pivot as necessary in response to changing conditions. Often agility is thought of as a trait most needed in rapidly changing industries, but those who think more deeply on the matter will appreciate that organization in slow changing industries are much more vulnerable to change, and so the value of leadership agility in that context is likely a much greater driver of value. Leaders who fail to recognize and respond to shifts in the strategic landscape risk being blindsided by more nimble competitors.
At its core, strategy requires that a leader be conversant with the major themes at play in the external environment, including market trends, customer needs, technological advancements, the actions of competitors, etc. It also requires introspection and insight into the organization’s internal environment, such as its resources, capabilities, culture, and goals. When the insights developed through careful reflection on the external and the internal are studiously aligned, leaders position themselves to chart a course of maximal value creation.
Strategy is about making choices, and developing a strategy demands choices as well. A rigorous process for developing an optimal strategy, i.e. choosing the game to be played, requires, to borrow a phrase from the character Bunk Moreland of The Wire, “soft eyes”. As the character goes on to explain: “If you’ve got soft eyes, you can see the whole thing. If you got hard eyes–you staring at the same tree missing the forest”. Strategy development requires of those in leadership the “soft eyes” ability to grasp the full picture without being lost in the minutiae. It is the ability to step back and reflect on the key elements of competition in one’s area, and to synthesize that holistic (macro) viewpoint with the extremely detailed (micro) viewpoint that all leaders operate within, that separates true strategic leaders from tacticians running someone else’s playbook.
Avoiding Strategy Misalignment
The consequences of adopting a suboptimal strategy framework can be severe. Leaders who misunderstand their own or their competitor’s strengths and weaknesses are poorly positioned to leverage their strengths or exploit their opponent’s weaknesses. Further, they likely lack the insight to fully appreciate the importance and implications of their own organizational weaknesses and their opponent’s strengths. This strategy myopia therefore can become the first step down a long and painful road of value destruction.
Thoughtful, reflective leaders are the key to fostering value creation and ensuring long-term success. Leaders must be proactive in understanding the strategic game they are playing and purposeful in their selection or creation of a strategy framework optimized for their organization.
A few key elements for leaders to consider as they investigate the appropriateness of their existing strategy framework:
Understand the Field of Play. The always on culture of executive leadership, combined with a fear of showing weakness, prevents many leaders from developing deep and useful insights into their industry, the changes on the horizon, and how those changes may play out. The mind of the strategist is a mind awash in possibilities, from the highly likely to the extremely unlikely, but every one of them useful and instructive in its own way. Leaders should cultivate deeper understanding for themselves and demand the same of their leadership teams.
Know Yourself.
Areas of Weakness. I am fond of taking my leadership teams through thought exercises in which we game out how we would “beat” our own organization. What are the weak points in the organization? In the late 1970s McKinsey popularized a framework which encouraged companies to divest business units if they were not the best possible owner of that business. This type of thinking can be extremely powerful, especially in the context of careful and constructive strategy development, which too often moves along a pre-determined path, innovating little and adding even less value.
Areas of Strength. Far too often, leaders are highly self-congratulatory on their perceived areas of organizational strength. Unfortunately, these areas of strength are often products of tribal wisdom and not firmly grounded in an understanding of the overall industry. Strength (and weakness) should not be viewed in absolute but in relative terms. A company that views itself as strong in customer service, despite its customer service function being objectively no better than any number of its competitors, is telling itself a story that is unproductive at best, likely distracting, and possibly harmful.
Know Your Opposition.
Areas of Strength. Competition can be a wonderful tool to aid in fostering a deeper level of strategic insight, but that deeper insight can only be achieved when leaders are able to overcome their biases and engage objectively with those areas in which competitors show strength relative to their own organization. Leaders must be willing to be brutally honest with themselves, because in assessing areas of strength of a competitor, you are assessing areas in which your competition is better than you.
Areas of Weakness. Absent extreme discipline, any exercise of listing the weaknesses of competitors can easily devolve into little more than a gripe session or an off-key diss track. Investing the time and effort to seriously interrogate areas of competitor weakness should be a matter of surfacing a limited number of serious weaknesses. Great care should be taken to ensure that this area of inquiry does not become an ego boosting but ultimately uninformative dead-end.
Conclusion
The burden placed on leaders today can be enormous, but in many respects the most important responsibility of anyone in a leadership position is to think deeply about what game your organization is playing, and to ensure that the game, or strategy framework, that you select is one that leverages your strengths, exploits your opponent’s weaknesses, or, ideally, both. When leaders take seriously their responsibility for adopting or developing an optimal strategy framework for their organization, they lay the groundwork for compelling value creation.
About the Author
David Johnson is the founder and managing partner of Abraxas Group, a boutique advisory firm focused on providing leadership and support services to companies in need of transformational change. He is an accomplished thought leader with multiple articles and speaking engagements on the topics of business transformation, change management, performance improvement, restructuring, turnaround, and value creation to his credit. David can be reached at: david@abraxasgp.com.



